Mount Pisgah Cemetery: Henderson’s Jewish Burial Ground

Mount Pisgah Cemetery on Zion Road grew from the efforts of Henderson’s Jewish women to establish permanent institutions for their community. The Hebrew Ladies Auxiliary Society raised $530 from 23 contributors and purchased the cemetery property in 1885. An Evansville rabbi conducted its consecration in 1886, before Adas Israel formally organized as a congregation the following year. 

The congregation subsequently built its synagogue at Alves and Center streets. Henry and Maurice Baldauf donated the site, and the temple was dedicated on September 17, 1892. Together, the synagogue and cemetery provided places for worship, remembrance, and the observance of Jewish traditions in Henderson. 

As the congregation diminished, preserving Mount Pisgah became an enduring responsibility. Recorded property documents identify a cemetery trust dated September 28, 1962, with First National Bank of Henderson serving as trustee. 

According to historian Frank Boyett, the remaining members later agreed to use proceeds from selling their synagogue to maintain the cemetery. The building was advertised for sale in 1965 and purchased by Christ Corner Church in 1966. That decision helped provide for the burial ground after the congregation could no longer sustain its house of worship.